April 23, 2025

When Leadership Ignores Data and Logic What Should You Do?

The Frustration of Watching a Bad Decision Unfold

You saw it coming from miles away. The numbers didn’t add up. The risks were obvious. The alternative solutions were right there. But despite your warnings, the decision was made. Top management, in their infinite wisdom, chose a path that you know will hurt the company. And now, you’re the one who has to execute it.

It’s frustrating. It’s disheartening. And if you’re like most supply chain professionals, it might even make you question your role. After all, what’s the point of your expertise if no one listens when it really matters? But here’s the thing—you did your job. You presented the data. You highlighted the risks. You gave them a way out. If they chose not to take it, that’s on them, not you.

Before we go further into this topic, don’t forget to follow my LinkedIn account. You’ll get more helpful insights on supply chain management there.

You Are Not the Decision Maker—And That’s Okay

In the world of supply chain, you’re constantly juggling data, supplier constraints, inventory levels, lead times, and cost efficiency. Your job is to provide the best possible recommendations based on real-world constraints. But at the end of the day, the final call is out of your hands.

Management isn’t always rational. Sometimes, decisions are made based on office politics, gut feelings, or an executive’s personal agenda. It’s maddening when you’ve spent weeks analyzing a problem only to have leadership brush off your findings. But as frustrating as it is, this is the reality of working in a structured organization. You’re part of the system, but you’re not the system itself.

That means you don’t have to carry the weight of their bad decisions. If things go south, it’s not your name on the line. It’s theirs. Your responsibility is to execute the decision to the best of your ability and minimize damage where you can. That’s it.

How to Handle the Inevitable Fallout

Of course, just because it’s not your decision doesn’t mean you can ignore the consequences. You still have a business to run, a team to manage, and a supply chain to keep afloat. So how do you move forward?

First, detach emotionally. You care about your work, and that’s a good thing. But getting emotionally invested in a battle you’ve already lost will only drain you. Accept that this is happening, no matter how irrational it is. Once you do that, you can shift your energy toward damage control.

Second, document everything. Keep records of your recommendations, the data you presented, and the decision-making process. This isn’t about saying “I told you so” later—it’s about protecting yourself and making sure there’s a clear trail of responsibility. If things go wrong, you want to be able to show that you did your due diligence.

Third, focus on what you can control. Maybe you can negotiate better terms with suppliers to offset some of the financial damage. Maybe you can adjust inventory strategies to prevent stockouts or excess. Maybe you can tweak production schedules to minimize inefficiencies. There’s always something you can do to lessen the impact, even if you can’t reverse the decision itself.

You might also like:

The Art of Letting Go

One of the hardest lessons in supply chain—and in any corporate environment—is learning to let go of things you can’t change. You’re a problem solver by nature. You want to fix things, to optimize, to create the best possible outcomes. But sometimes, the biggest win is recognizing when a fight isn’t worth fighting anymore.

Letting go doesn’t mean giving up. It means being strategic about where you put your energy. It means accepting that leadership will make bad calls, and you can’t stop all of them. It means understanding that your value isn’t just in making good recommendations, but also in handling difficult situations when they arise.

When It All Comes Crashing Down

Here’s the ironic part—when things start going wrong (and they will), the same leadership that ignored your warnings might suddenly ask, “How did this happen?” They might scramble for solutions. They might even look to you to fix the mess.

This is where your professionalism comes in. You could say, “I told you so,” but that won’t get you anywhere. Instead, calmly present the facts. Show them the data again. Offer a plan to mitigate further losses. If they’re willing to listen this time, great. If not, you still document everything and keep moving forward.

Designed by Freepik

Your Career Isn’t Defined by Their Mistakes

At the end of the day, you’re building your reputation, not theirs. How you handle these situations—staying professional, keeping your composure, focusing on solutions—will define your career far more than the bad decisions of upper management.

So don’t let this eat at you. Don’t carry the weight of a bad call that wasn’t yours to make. You did your job. Now, do what you can with what you have and let the rest play out as it will.

You might also like:

Navigating Office Politics and Executive Egos

It’s tempting to believe that all decisions should be data-driven, but the corporate world doesn’t always work that way. Decisions are often influenced by factors you’re not privy to—executive relationships, hidden agendas, or even just plain ego. When management makes a choice that contradicts the numbers, sometimes it’s not ignorance—it’s self-preservation.

This is why understanding office politics is almost as crucial as understanding supply chain metrics. You don’t have to play the game, but you do have to be aware of it. Knowing who influences decisions and why can help you position your recommendations more effectively in the future.

Preparing for the Next Time This Happens (Because It Will)

Bad decisions aren’t a one-time thing. If you’ve been in this industry long enough, you know it’s only a matter of time before it happens again. So instead of getting frustrated every time, prepare for it.

Work on your communication skills. Sometimes, the way you present data can make or break its impact. Learn how to frame your arguments in a way that resonates with executives, not just fellow supply chain professionals. Connect the numbers to business outcomes that leadership cares about—profitability, risk exposure, customer satisfaction.

Build allies in the organization. Find other data-driven colleagues, whether in finance, operations, or sales, who can back up your insights. When multiple departments align on a recommendation, it’s harder to ignore.

Develop resilience. If you let every poor leadership decision get to you, you’ll burn out quickly. Instead, adopt a mindset where you expect setbacks but stay focused on the bigger picture—building a career where your voice matters, regardless of individual missteps by leadership.

Final Thought: Own Your Expertise, But Not Their Mistakes

You can’t control bad leadership decisions, but you can control how you respond to them. Keep doing your job well. Keep pushing for the right decisions. Keep documenting your insights. And when things go wrong, remember—it’s not your responsibility to fix leadership’s mistakes.

You’re in this for the long haul. Stay focused, stay professional, and don’t let the frustration of today derail the success of tomorrow.

I hope you find it helpful!

Please share this article with your colleagues so they can also benefit. For more insights on supply chain management, follow my LinkedIn account. You’re free to use all articles on this blog for any purpose, even for commercial use, without needing to give credit.

Avatar photo

Dicky Saputra

I am a professional working in Supply Chain Management since 2004. I help companies improve their overall supply chain performance.

View all posts by Dicky Saputra →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *